It was an unceremonious end to the Packers’ season as they lost to the Philadelphia Eagles in the wild card round. Philadelphia would qualify for Super Bowl LIX just a few weeks later.
Two consecutive playoff appearances by Green Bay with Jordan Love at quarterback bodes well for its future. There is little doubt, however, that this team is a few pieces away from being a Super Bowl contender.
The future of NFL officiating is also at the forefront of many fans’ minds. Green Bay’s president Mark Murphy took the time to comment on this exact concern.
Packers’ President Comments On “Officiating Favoritism” Ahead Of Eagles-Chiefs Super Bowl (Report)
In Mark Murphy’s Take Five Segment, he commented on favoritism of NFL referees:
Paul from Chicago, IL
Thank you for your long and successful tenure with the Packers. As a longtime reader, I’ve always admired how you take on the tough questions directly and without flinching. Recently I (as well as many of the fans I know, who support many different teams) have become concerned about the quality of the officiating.
I believe there is a general emerging consensus among the fans that not only is the officiating not good enough, it also seems at times unfair and to favor certain teams and players. In the past I have not given much weight to these claims, but recently I find them harder to ignore.
As a representative of the league, what would you say to fans like myself who have begun to question the game’s officiating and basic fairness, and what plans does the league have to help improve public confidence in this critical area?
This was Murphy’s response:
I appreciate you raising this issue, Paul. I have heard from a number of people recently about the quality of officiating in the league (I do have a lot of friends who are Bills fans). I have served on league committees that work closely with officials, and have gained tremendous respect for the officials in our league.
They have a very hard job that has become more difficult over the years with the speed of the game increasing (and the league becoming more of a passing league). Also, they are true professionals who take great pride in their work. I can assure you that they do not favor certain teams or players. The league office is key to the quality of officiating. They select, train and evaluate the officials.
All officials are graded for each game they officiate, and the highest-graded officials work the playoff games. In terms of public confidence, I think it would help if people were more aware of all the training (and evaluation) that the league officials go through during both the season and offseason.
Murphy emphatically stated that there is absolutely no favoritism in the NFL. The off-season training that Murphy talked about his highlighted here:
In 2023, NFL teams ran more than 43,000 plays. The NFL Officiating Department meticulously reviewed its officials’ performance on every one of them. Every play. Every game.
Each game averages about 153 plays, so a typical official who works 14 regular-season games is evaluated on nearly 2,200 plays in a single season. The Officiating Department reviews game footage looking for the calls that were made correctly — and also the ones that were missed.
There is nowhere to hide on the football field. Whether working a closely contested Super Bowl or the final minutes of a preseason game, officials are expected to exhibit the same high level of excellence on every play.
They are carefully selected, extensively prepared and rigorously evaluated to ensure that they call games correctly and consistently. This process results in the outstanding officiating that players, coaches and fans expect and deserve.
Officiating an NFL game — making split-second decisions at full speed and at field level — takes decades of work and dedication. While fans may not always agree with every call, one thing is certain: These officials are good.
